Cameron's EU stance is unsustainable and the sceptics know it

Cameron's EU stance is unsustainable and the sceptics know it

Cameron's EU stance is unsustainable and the sceptics know it

19 July 2012
From New Statesman

Link to press quote:
http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/politics/2012/07/camerons-eu-stance-unsustainable-and-sceptics-know-it

Tory MPs look to Norway model on EU

Tory MPs look to Norway model on EU

Tory MPs look to Norway model on EU

By Charles Grant, 02 July 2012
From Financial Times

Britain, Europe and the City of London: Can the triangle be managed?

Britain, Europe and the City of London

Britain, Europe and the City of London: Can the triangle be managed?

Written by Philip Whyte, 20 July 2012

What Central Europe thinks of Britain and why

What Central Europe thinks of Britain and why

What Central Europe thinks of Britain and why

Written by Tomas Valasek, 16 July 2012

Britain's Conservative Party is committed to repatriating powers from the EU. On July 12th, Foreign Secretary William Hague launched a review of the EU's competences. This would, he told Parliament, be an "audit of…where competence lies, how the EU's competences, whether exclusive, shared or supporting, are used, and what that means for our national interest." Many Conservatives expect this audit to prepare the ground for a manifesto commitment to renegotiate the terms of Britain's EU membership. They hope that Britain can obtain opt-outs in areas such as financial services, judicial co-operation, employment, migration, regional policy or fisheries. They argue that Britain's partners will wish to change the EU treaties to cope with the eurozone crisis, and that Britain can trade off the repatriation of powers in return for its signature.

However, any British opt-out would require the unanimous agreement of every other member-state. Conversations with diplomats from Central Europe suggest that there is very little goodwill towards London, even among its formerly stalwart allies.

The Central Europeans see the UK as an important partner. When David Cameron circulated a letter in February 2012 outlining single market reforms that would revive the European economy, five of the eleven co-signatories came from Central Europe, with Germany and France the notable absentees. The new member-states sided with London against Paris and Berlin over the Iraq war, and the UK shares their desire to bring more Balkan countries into the EU – again, against much scepticism from many continental countries.

And yet the UK cannot count on all Central Europeans to support its demand for opt-outs from EU legislation. This is for two reasons: Germany has become the central focus of the region’s foreign policies, and Britain has come to be seen by other member-states as taking advantage of the common currency's existential troubles to defend its narrow interests.

Germany is by far the largest investor in Central Europe, and its economy is deeply embedded in the wider region. When I asked a former finance minister from Central Europe to predict his country's growth rate, he replied "take Germany’s number and add one percentage point". Most Central European governments also assume that there is a possibility of the eurozone fracturing and losing some of its member-states. If and when it happens, they want to remain a part of the Berlin-led economic core. London will be of little help in such a crisis – it is too far away, has too few investments in Central Europe, and wants to have less and less to do with the EU in general. So the new member-states (and others in similar situations such as Denmark or the Netherlands) will have few reasons for wanting to spend political capital on supporting UK demands for exemptions from EU legislation, especially if Germany opposes them (and senior officials in Berlin take a hard line in opposing British attempts to repatriate powers).


Furthermore, the UK offers nothing in return (it is not contributing to the eurozone bailout fund) and Britain’s exemptions may adversely affect other countries’ economies. They fear, for example, that if the UK relaxes social protection for workers (a key Conservative demand), businesses elsewhere in Europe will migrate to the UK. "London is engaging in 'beggar-thy-neighbour' tactics", one official from Central Europe told me (though France and others say the same of the new member-states' low corporate tax rate). In December 2011 Britain threatened to veto the proposed ‘fiscal compact’ to secure an opt-out from rules governing financial services. But the tactic misfired – the rest of the EU minus the Czech Republic agreed to form the compact anyway; they did so outside existing EU treaties and without Britain. Any future banking or fiscal union will almost certainly be organised in a similar way, a Baltic diplomat told me, because the UK and the Czech Republic – and possibly others – do not want closer integration. This leaves London without any good means to pressure others to secure its opt-outs. "The rest of the EU now knows that it is possible to isolate Britain, and they are more willing than ever to do so. It is not clear that Britain realises that", the official said.

Nothing has hurt Britain's image elsewhere in Europe more than the perception that London is failing to help to end the crisis and – worse – that the UK is taking advantage of others' woes. A Polish official told me that during the December 2011 negotiations London lobbied Warsaw to stay out of the fiscal compact. Its creation is a key part of the member-states’ efforts to stop the run on their sovereign debt. The fact that Britain not only decided against joining it but sought to discourage other non-euro countries from doing so – presumably to avoid being isolated – has been seen by many as an act of remarkable ill will. According to a senior Baltic official "Britain is a nuisance; it imposes an additional burden on us of having to go around it, complicating negotiations". This is not entirely fair: British proposals on how to stimulate economic growth, which many Central European governments signed, are among the most thoughtful of such contributions. But European diplomats think that London puts a lot more energy into demanding special deals for itself than solving the crisis.

The Central European officials I interviewed sounded genuinely regretful of Britain's growing estrangement from the EU – there was no sense of 'good riddance' or gloating. But Britain’s likely demands for opt-outs from EU policies will have very little support from them (with the possible exception of the Czech Republic). A dangerous situation has emerged. Even though the government in London seems likely to attempt to unpick some of its ties, rather than sever them all, it risks rejection. And would a bruised UK want to remain in the EU? The Central Europeans fear that Britain may drop out in anger, in effect leaving the EU by accident rather than by design. But, as one Polish official acknowledged "as long as the eurozone is a mess, Britain will not want to be shackled to a sinking ship. We need to sort out our banks and economies first, thus giving London the reason to stay".

Tomas Valasek is director of foreign policy and defence at the Centre for European Reform.

Comments

Added on 18 Oct 2012 at 00:38 by xxx

We are all European. World-level investors see Europe as one so we better stick together rather than follow old-fashioned us-and-we demagogy, especially challenged by other economic blocks, or even individual countries.

It's quite nice to invest in Central Europe (I wouldn't really use Central and Eastern, since the centre of the continent is in eastern Lithuania), so new markets and customers may become available to the rest in the nearest future.

Child allowance- perhaps some,
Free dentistry - not really - every single visit is paid at least £12, while in most EU countries, including Central Europe, it is absolutely free.
Free NHS - well, Britain isn't the only country to have universal healthcare. In fact it was one of the last ones to have it. It is only thanks to Atlee that Britain's poor don't die like in the US.
Education - well, PISA results in Central Europe demonstrate that even without EU funding the Education in Central Europe is generally one of the best in the world.
Housing - it's again a European thing - a standard rather than something distinctive to the UK.

I wonder if you travel at all.

I also wonder why Britain is not taking its advantage in the EU. It is a big country that could seek for alliance, like Germany, create its bloc, perhaps with conservatives in other EU countries, like Spain, perhaps the Czech Republic and Hungary...

Added on 19 Jul 2012 at 10:20 by Sue

You won't need our £50 million a day contribution then? Much of which has supported modernisation of your countries' infrastructure (as ours falls to pieces).

Presumably, the citizens of central & eastern europe, of which there are well over a million working in the UK will be happy to return to their homelands?

I won't even mention those that are receiving the UK's generous benefits including child allowance, free dentistry, free NHS and education and housing.

All the UK government is asking for is a little more control over our governance. You are fortunate that our leaders are pro-EU, if it were up to the electorate, we'd have been out years ago.

Added on 18 Jul 2012 at 20:56 by EUtopia

The UK's reputation has lately been severely damaged by its refusal to cooperate with the financial transaction tax. Anyway, important post, because no one talks about Central Europe these days.

Hollande visit fraught with friction

Hollande visit fraught with friction

Hollande visit fraught with friction

By Charles Grant, 09 July 2012
From Financial Times

The Socialist, the Tory, and the queen: Hollande visits UK

The Socialist, the Tory, and the queen: Hollande visits UK

The Socialist, the Tory, and the queen: Hollande visits UK

By Philip Whyte, 10 July 2012
From The Christian Science Monitor

Link to press quote:
http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Europe/2012/0710/The-Socialist-the-Tory-and-the-queen-Hollande-visits-UK

Le débat sur la sortie de l'UE s'amplifie au Royaume-Uni

Le débat sur la sortie de l'UE s'amplifie au Royaume-Uni

Le débat sur la sortie de l'UE s'amplifie au Royaume-Uni

05 July 2012
From Le Monde

Vote to impeach president adds to turmoil in Romania

Vote to impeach president adds to turmoil in Romania

Vote to impeach president adds to turmoil in Romania

By Hugo Brady, 06 July 2012
From The New York Times

Link to press quote:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/07/world/europe/romania-parliament-votes-to-impeach-traian-basescu.html?_r=1

Syndicate content